This 2013 paper investigated the experiences of Members of the Welsh Assembly elected for the first time in 2011. The research was conducted as part of the Hansard Society’s comparative ‘A Year in the Life’ study of new legislators. According to the paper, new AMs felt that the Assembly was not as effective as it could be, nor as distinct as it should be.

In 2011 the National Assembly for Wales commissioned the Hansard Society to extend to Cardiff our ‘A Year in the Life’ study of new Westminster MPs, in order to provide the Assembly with independent research about the experiences of new Assembly Members in their first year, especially regarding their attitudes to the orientation and induction provided.

The research in turn informed the provision of professional development support during the 2011-2016 Assembly term, and the curation of the induction programme for new AMs after the 2016 election.

Research into the 2011 intake was especially pertinent because that year saw the turnover of over 30% of Assembly Members, the largest since the Assembly came into existence in 1999.

And the 2011-2016 term also opened with the Assembly having already undergone considerable change in its powers and structures, even in its relatively short life, but with a live debate underway both inside and outside the institution about the need for further reform, in which the views of AMs would be crucial in shaping any future changes.

To conduct the ‘A Year in the Life’ research in Cardiff, from summer 2011 the Hansard Society monitored the role and work of the new AMs, through surveys, interviews and personal observation, supplemented by discussions with Assembly staff.

The research found that, overall, new AMs were more satisfied with the aspects of their role to do with constituency work than with their role as legislators in the Assembly. Perhaps reflecting the lack of time and space to step back and think strategically about their role and work, AMs had few concrete suggestions for reform. However, they did have a sense that the Assembly was not as effective as it could be, and not as distinct as it should be, given the aspirations at the time of devolution that Cardiff should be different from Westminster. The report suggested that the problems facing AMs were as much cultural as procedural, and that political space was needed for an inclusive discussion transcending party lines and focusing on the challenges AMs share in common.

Table of contents

  • Introduction
  • The new AMs: their backgrounds and the road to Cardiff Bay
  • Arriving at the Senedd
  • The role and work of a new Assembly Member
  • The workings of the Assembly
  • One year on
  • Methodology

Enjoy reading this? Please consider sharing it

Latest

Erskine May online
blog / 04.07.19

Freeing ‘Erskine May’: getting the authoritative guide to Parliament’s procedures and practice online

‘Erskine May’, the authoritative guide to Parliament’s procedures and practice, went online on 2 July. The move has significant implications for democratic transparency and for Parliament’s interaction with the public. Here, one of the editors of the new edition, Clerk of the Journals Mark Hutton, explains why and how the innovation came about.

Freeing ‘Erskine May’: getting the authoritative guide to Parliament’s procedures and practice online
Pound coins
blog / 02.07.19

Power of the Purse: what is the Estimates process and how does it work?

Some backbench MPs are seeking to use House of Commons approval of the government’s Main Estimates for 2019-20 as a vehicle against a ‘no-deal’ Brexit, meaning the process is attracting greater interest than usual. We set out how the Estimates process works, how it has changed over the years, and how it could be improved in the future.

Power of the Purse: what is the Estimates process and how does it work?
40th Anniversary of the creation of Departmental Select Committees
blog / 01.07.19

The increased stature of select committees and their chairs: reflections by Harriet Harman MP

On the 40th anniversary of the creation of departmental select committees, Harriet Harman, the longest continuously-serving woman MP, offers some personal reflections on the growing importance of select committees and their chairs, particularly at a time of considerable political instability.

The increased stature of select committees and their chairs: reflections by Harriet Harman MP
Sunset over Big Ben, Houses of Parliament, Westminster
blog / 11.06.19

Waiting for who? House of Commons business before the summer recess

The focus is on what might happen at the end of the pre-summer Commons sitting period now underway – rightly, given its potential political and constitutional significance. But the dearth of government legislative business means the six weeks before then could present opportunities for the opposition, backbenchers and select committees, including on Brexit.

Waiting for who? House of Commons business before the summer recess
Prev
Next